Architectural Roof Shingles vs. 3-Tab: A Comprehensive Comparison

Your roof keeps the entire house safe and sound. That’s why picking the suitable roofing material is so important, and asphalt shingles are the best option for many people when choosing the roof type.

This guide will help you understand the difference between architectural  and 3-tab shingles. Knowing their distinctions can help you decide which one suits you best.

What are Architectural Shingles?

A rooftop with two dormer windows covered in architectural shingles

Architectural shingles are a unique roofing material that’s becoming very popular, especially for new houses. Some people call them dimensional or laminated shingles because of their distinctive construction and appearance.

These roofing materials are crafted by bonding multiple layers of bitumen and fibreglass, creating a three-dimensional look with depth and texture. 

This laminated structure mimics the appearance of natural materials like timber or slate and enhances durability and weather resistance. They both highlight the shingles’ multi-layered design, allowing for more complex patterns and substantial profile than traditional flat bitumen shingles. They’re meant to keep your roof safe and make it look flashy.

How Are They Made?

Think of architectural shingles like a sandwich for your roof. They have more than one layer, which makes them thicker and more challenging. They start with a bottom layer, then more layers are stuck on top.

This clever design means:

  1. They’re more robust and last ages.

  2. They can look like posh materials, like slate or wooden shakes.

  3. You can get them in heaps of different colours and styles.

Why Do People Like Them?

Lots of people are choosing architectural shingles for their homes. Here’s why:

  1. They’re tough: Being thicker means they can handle rough weather better than some other roof coverings. They often last 30 years or more!

  2. They look mint: The layers create shadows on your roof, making your house look fancy. This can even increase its value.

  3. They go with everything: Architectural shingles are available to match any house, whether modern or old-school.

  4. They’re not too dear: They cost a bit more than basic shingles, but many reckon they’re worth it because they last longer and look nicer.

So, if you need a new roof, consider architectural shingles. They’re a good choice if you want something that looks good and lasts.

What are 3-Tab Shingles?

3-Tab Shingles are a common type of roofing that’s been around for donkey’s years. They’re called “3-tab” because each shingle has three flaps. Many people choose these for their homes, especially when watching their pennies.

How Are They Made?

3-Tab Shingles are pretty simple:

  1. They’re flat: Unlike fancy shingles, these are just one flat piece.

  2. Simple look: Each shingle is a rectangle with three even-sized bits cut into it.

  3. Thin and light: They don’t weigh much because they’re not layered.

What They're Used For?

People have been putting 3-tab shingles on roofs for ages. Here’s why:

  1. Dead cheap: 3-tab shingles won’t break the bank if you’re a bit skint.

  2. Easy as to put on: Roofers can slap them on quickly, which saves you dosh on workers.

  3. Keep the rain out: They might not last as long as dear ones, but they do the job.

  4. Look alright: These fit the bill if you want your house to look regular and casual.

So, 3-Tab Shingles might not be the bee’s knees, but they’re good if you want a roof that works without costing an arm and a leg. They’re like the trusty old bike of roofs – not flash, but they get you where you need to go!

Architectural or 3-Tab Shingles?

The Look

Comparison of 3-tab shingles on the left and architectural shingles on the right.

First, let’s talk about how these shingles look on your roof.

Architectural shingles

They are the fancy ones. They have a bit of texture, which gives your roof some depth. They’re like trying to look posh, with different shapes and shadows. If your roof were a haircut, these would be the stylish layered look.

3-tab shingles

They’re flat, and all look the same, like a crew cut for your house. Nothing flashy, just a neat appearance.

How Tough Are They?

Which type of shingle holds up better against severe weather – architectural or 3-tab?

Architectural shinglesThese are thicker and heavier, so they can handle more of what the weather throws. It’s like they’ve been hitting the gym regularly.
3-tab shinglesThey are a bit more delicate. They’re thinner and lighter, which isn’t always a bad thing, but it does mean they might not be as strong in a fight against a big storm.

How Long Do They Last?

This is important because nobody wants to replace their roof too often, right?

Architectural shinglesAre in it for the long haul. They usually stick around for 20 to 30 years, sometimes even longer if you treat them nicely. It’s like they’ve signed a long-term contract with your house.
3-tab shingles Don’t hang around as long. They usually last about 15 to 20 years. Still a decent amount of time, but not as long as their architectural mates.

What About the Cost?

When it comes to the cost, how do architectural shingles stack up against 3-tab options?
3-tab shingles They are easier on the wallet upfront. They’re the budget-friendly option, costing less to buy and install. If you’re watching your pennies, these might be your go-to choice.
Architectural shingles  These are pricier to start with. You’ll need to fork out more cash initially for these fancy fellas. But here’s the thing – they might save you money in the long run.  Because they last longer, you won’t need to replace them as often. It’s like buying a good pair of boots instead of cheap ones you have to replace every year.
So, when you’re thinking about cost, don’t just look at the price tag. Consider how long they’ll last and how often you’ll need to replace them. Sometimes, spending a bit more now can save you a bundle later!

Durability and Weather Resistance

Let’s talk about how these shingles handle the weather. After all, your roof is like your home’s umbrella!

Architectural shingles

They’re heavier and thicker, which means they can better withstand strong winds, heavy rain, and even hail than their 3-tab cousins.


They’re less likely to blow off in a storm or crack under pressure. Think of them as the all-weather jacket of roofing.

3-tab shingles

They aren’t as sturdy but can still protect your home. However, they might struggle more in extreme weather. 


They’re more likely to lift in high winds or be damaged by falling branches. It’s like wearing a light raincoat—fine for a drizzle but not great in a downpour.

Aesthetic Appeal and Home Value

Now, let’s discuss how these shingles can make your house look.

Architectural shinglesThey are the real lookers. They add depth and character to your roof, making your house look fancier. Some say they make a house look more expensive (even if it isn’t!). 
If you’re thinking of selling your home down the line, these shingles might bump up your property value a bit.
3-tab shingles 

They are more about function than fashion. They provide a clean and uniform appearance to your roof, but they don’t add much visual interest or distinctiveness.

They’re like a plain white t-shirt – they do the job, but they’re not winning any style awards. They probably won’t add much to your home’s value, but they won’t take away from it either.

Ease of Installation and Maintenance

Installing and maintaining your roofing system efficiently can significantly extend its lifespan and reduce long-term costs.
3-tab shingles They are easier to install, lighter, and simpler to work with, so the job gets done faster.   They’re also pretty straightforward to replace if one gets damaged—it’s a bit like switching out a Lego brick.
Architectural shingles These are a bit trickier to install. They’re heavier and more complex, so getting them on your roof takes more time and skill. But once they’re on, they tend to need less maintenance over time because they’re tougher. It’s like installing a fancy appliance – more work to set up, but easier to live with.

Which Type of Shingle Is Best for You?

Alright, so we’ve thrown a lot of info at you. How do you choose? Here are some things to think about:

  1. Your budget: If you need to keep costs down right now, 3-tab shingles might be your best bet. But if you can spend more upfront for potential savings later, consider architectural shingles.

  2. Your home’s style: Architectural shingles can add a touch of class to older or more upscale homes. But 3-tab shingles might fit better with simpler house styles.

  3. Your long-term plans: If you’re planning to sell soon, architectural shingles might boost your home’s kerb appeal. If you’re staying put for ages, think about which option will serve you best over time.

Final Thoughts

Alright, let’s wrap this up with a quick recap and some final advice.

We’ve covered a lot about architectural and 3-tab shingles. Here’s a quick reminder of the main differences:

  1. Design: Architectural shingles have a textured, dimensional look, while 3-tab shingles are flat and uniform.

  2. Cost: 3-tab shingles are cheaper upfront, but architectural shingles might save you money in the long run.

  3. Durability: Architectural shingles are tougher and last longer, typically 20-30 years compared to 15-20 years for 3-tab shingles.

  4. Maintenance: 3-tab shingles are easier to install and repair, but architectural shingles generally need less maintenance over time.

  5. Your climate: If you live somewhere with wild weather, architectural shingles might be worth the extra cost for their durability.

Remember, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer when it comes to choosing shingles. It’s important to think about:

  • Your budget (both short-term and long-term)

  • Where you live (consider your local weather patterns)

  • Your future plans (are you staying put or planning to sell?)

These factors will help you decide which type of shingle is best for your home.

Lastly, while we hope this guide has been helpful, there’s no substitute for professional advice. Every home is unique, Our roofing expert team can give you personalised recommendations based on your specific situation. We will consider your roof’s pitch, local building codes, and other factors we haven’t covered here.

Ready to take action?

Contact Residential & Commercial Roofing today at 0800 880 066 or visit our website for architectural shingles and 3-tab shingles roofing services. Our experienced team is standing by to discuss your roofing needs, provide a consultation, and offer a competitive quote. Don’t let roofing worries hang over your head—call us now and secure the quality roof your home deserves!

Canterbury's Trusted Residential and Commercial Roofing Experts

Complete Address(Required)